If you agree that the problem is not a chaos problem where there are too many factors of the same degree of importance, there should be a simple, clear-cut picture out there. That picture might be not easy to establish in the beginning, but it should exist. I feel that three-footed cat's argument has such a quality. If his argument is valid, Ye's cooked data immediately become obvious for everyone, even for a layman.I'm not an expert in this area, but if three-footed cat's argument is legitemate, I'm 100% sure Ye and his students not only fabricated their data, but also lack training in high school,that does not make a surprise though.