◇◇新语丝(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)◇◇ 司马米鼠对项家兄弟博士生数量统计有误 龙不平 司马米鼠“辱骂人的美国退休教授项武义：儒林小档案”一文中，指称“项武义 在加州大学任教的漫长岁月中，竟只带过一名博士生”，又称“项武忠在普林斯 顿大学漫长的任教期间，也只带过一名博士生”。这两项说法都是错误的。 根据Mathematical Genealogy的统计，项武义教授在加州大学至少带过有十几名 博士生：（http://genealogy.math.ndsu.nodak.edu/html/id.phtml?id=6607） Christopher Allday University of California, Berkeley 1970 Helmer Aslaksen University of California, Berkeley 1988 Allen Back University of California, Berkeley 1977 Ted (Theodore) Chang University of California, Berkeley 1972 2 Dogan Donmez University of California, Berkeley 1983 Nicholas Ercolani University of California, Berkeley 1980 9 David Golber The University of Chicago 1969 1 Jesus Gonzalo University of California, Berkeley 1991 Claudio Gorodski University of California, Berkeley 1992 1 Edward Grove Brown University 1969 4 Hsueh-Ling Huynh University of California, Berkeley 1993 Bruce Kleiner University of California, Berkeley 1990 2 Seng-Hwang Lee University of California, Berkeley 1993 Renato Pedrosa University of California, Berkeley 1988 Tor Skjelbred University of California, Berkeley 1972 Ivan Sterling University of California, Berkeley 1985 Eldar Straume University of California, Berkeley 1978 Richard Sullivan The University of Chicago 1969 Nicholas Torre University of California, Berkeley 1989 McKenzie Wang Stanford University 1980 1 Paul Wolfson The University of Chicago 1973 而项武忠教授在普林斯顿大学也至少带过8名博士生 （http://genealogy.math.ndsu.nodak.edu/html/id.phtml?id=8591）： Douglas Anderson Yale University 1966 2 Ruth Charney Princeton University 1977 5 Michael Davis Princeton University 1975 5 F. Thomas Farrell Yale University 1967 7 Thomas Goodwillie Princeton University 1982 8 Ian Hambleton Yale University 1973 4 Bj?rn Jahren Princeton University 1975 2 Lowell Jones Yale University 1970 3 Ayelet Lindenstrauss Princeton University 1992 Andrew Nicas Princeton University 1979 Robert Oliver Princeton University 1974 1 Elliott Stein Princeton University 1975 另外，带过博士生数量的多少并不是学术水平的重要标准。例如国际著名的数学 大师、费马大定理的证明者Andrew Wiles迄今带过的博士生似乎只有13名 （http://genealogy.math.ndsu.nodak.edu/html/id.phtml?id=9696），还没有 项武义教授多。 (XYS200560914) ◇◇新语丝(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)◇◇