◇◇新语丝(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.dropin.org)(xys-reader.org)◇◇

对于《最年轻973首席郭熙志的NIH“优秀博士后杰出研究奖”是假的》的回复

郭熙志

方先生：您好！

　　从最近接到的美国的朋友来信中得知新语丝上关于我的一些评论。首先谢谢
大家的关心，也谢谢"不在此山中"近乎合理的推论。

　　我应该有责任就有关问题向社会作个交代：

　　1. 我于2007年拿到上海交通大学的offer, 并申请到973基金，于今年年初
举家回国，全职回国服务。世界上几乎每一个人都会采取先获得faculty 
position和努力申请grant，再辞去手头职务的做法。

　　2.  973申请过程中，申请书的主要内容由我本人书写并参加所有答辩。

　　3. 我发表的论文远不止两篇，我所列的这两篇是发表在本领域最权威的杂
志（Gene&Development,   Developmental Cell），特别是前者，方先生曾在网
页上也专门推荐过。（目前一般认为一篇好论文可以顶上上百篇一般论文）.

　　4. 我所获得的美国国立卫生研究院优秀博士后研究奖(Fellows Award for 
Research Excellence)获奖时间是 2004年，但NIH将9月份之后的都归到了2005
财政年度。（参考附件和NIH原始Email通知）。Yush给的链接中2005年的正好打
不开，即得出造假结论对于任何科学工作者来说都是伤害极大的。

　　5. 关于博士学位问题，我必须道歉的是关于"2003年获得博士学位" ，实际
是2003年获得博士毕业资格，离开中国赴美做博士后（访问学者）。至于学位证
书为什么2006年才发下来，欢迎询问中国科学院研究生部。 

　　最后，希望大家在大胆假设的时候，千万别忘了小心求证，这才是严谨的科
学态度。

谢谢！

下为NIH的原始获奖通知

>
>DATE:  August 19, 2004
>
>
>
>TO:    Dr. Xizhi  Guo
>FROM:  FARE 2005 Committee
>SUBJECT:  FARE 2005
>
>
>  Thank you for participating in the Fellows Award for Research Excellence
>(FARE) 2005 competition. The FARE 2005 Committee is pleased to announce that
>you have won a FARE 2005 Award based on scientific merit, originality,
>experimental design and overall quality/presentation of your submitted
>abstract entitled:
>
>Wnt/beta-catenin signaling is sufficient and necessary to induce synoval
>joint formation
>
>Similar to previous years, we were able to distribute FARE awards to
>twenty-five percent of the 939 applicants, or 240 awardees.  FARE 2005 was
>sponsored by the Scientific Directors, NIH Office of Education, NIH Office
>of Research on Women's Health, as well as the NIH Fellows Committee
>(FELCOM).
>
>  The FARE 2005 Award is a $1000 travel award that you can use to present
>your work at a scientific meeting.  Your Institute/Center is responsible for
>dispensing your travel award.  Information about how to activate your award
>must be obtained from the individual at your institute who is responsible
>for processing travel requests, such as your laboratory/branch secretary or
>administrative officer.  Additional questions should be addressed to your
>Scientific Director.  Details pertaining to travel sponsored by the United
>States Government, such as per diem rates, may be found at
>http://policyworks.gov/.  Please note that the FARE 2005 travel award must
>be used during Fiscal-Year 2005, i.e., between October 1, 2004 and September
>30, 2005.
>
>In addition to receiving this travel award you are expected to:
>
>?present your winning abstract to the NIH community during a poster session
>on October 12, 2004
>?participate as a postdoctoral judge for FARE 2006 (we will contact you next
>spring regarding this service)
>
>
>A FARE Award ceremony is scheduled on October 12, 2004 from 11am- 12 noon on
>the Bethesda campus.  Information pertaining to the ceremony, as well as the
>poster presentation, will be sent to you at a later date.
>
>You can activate your FARE award right away; you do not have to wait until
>the official
>FARE ceremony to start using your award.
>
>Congratulations and good luck!
>
>
>The FARE 2005 Committee,
>
>Mi Hillefors, MD, PHD    Kawsar Talaat, MD
>Janaki Kuruppu, MD     Joseph Mattapallil, DVM, PhD
>Susan Sparks, MD, PhD    Nikolay Nikolov, MD
>Catherine Jozwik, PhD    Robin Wilson, PhD

(XYS20080123)

◇◇新语丝(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.dropin.org)(xys-reader.org)◇◇