请问steven

所有跟贴·加跟贴·新语丝读书论坛

送交者: 揍汉奸于 2007-01-05, 17:53:23:

回答: this is very fake, the author doesn't know dogfight at all. 由 steven 于 2007-01-05, 17:32:38:

原文里哪里提到在转弯时开炮击中敌机？就凭你自己树个靶子就否认战果？

志愿军方面毫不讳言此次空战的失利。战斗中，志愿军空军击落美军空军飞机3架，自己被击落8架(其中有三架图-2轰炸机)。

所有跟贴:

Are you able to count? What you said does not go along with - 何人可 (221 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:54:12 (118822)
- 您再好好读一读？ - 揍汉奸 (274 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:09:37 (118828)
- 统计不精确，伤、亡不分，伤、落也不分 (无内容) - JZ (0 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:59:41 (118825)
  - 这个不过是个新闻报道 - 揍汉奸 (46 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:15:12 (118831)
    - Could you soly rely on <抗美援朝战争史> for the fact? Have you - 何人可 (104 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:21:47 (118835)
      - 呵呵，我至少还有本书作为讨论的依据 - 揍汉奸 (20 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:30:05 (118838)
        
        Wrong information hurts much worse than no information at all! (无内容) - 何人可 (0 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:33:16 (118841)
        
        呵呵，您以为您是谁？ - 揍汉奸 (61 bytes) 2007-01-05, 20:19:33 (118859)
        
        除了说明你在胡说后才找的资料还能说明什么？ - janz (94 bytes) 2007-01-06, 12:48:08 (118965)
        
        Please see my new post above. Thanks! (无内容) - 何人可 (0 bytes) 2007-01-06, 05:22:14 (118930)
        
        你愿意相信什么，说什么都行，最少也要拿出一些有分量的证据再说话。 - janz (56 bytes) 2007-01-06, 05:17:04 (118929)
        
        Even a nobody should have the rights to express doubts on something fishy. (无内容) - 何人可 (0 bytes) 2007-01-06, 02:14:31 (118922)
        
        任何一只军队的战史都有错误 - 揍汉奸 (220 bytes) 2007-01-06, 00:27:15 (118912)
        
        跟错了，是给何人可的。 - janz (116 bytes) 2007-01-05, 23:28:31 (118904)
        
        真无聊，你要是觉得资料不对，去找出正确的反驳他啊？ - janz (120 bytes) 2007-01-05, 23:25:25 (118903)
        
        对中国方面的史料, I don't always 抱定死不承认的态度. But, this time, - 何人可 (364 bytes) 2007-01-05, 23:19:43 (118902)
        
        土共方面的战史确实有很多错 - 揍汉奸 (310 bytes) 2007-01-05, 21:08:27 (118873)
        
        The track record of the mainland publications made me think so. (无内容) - 何人可 (0 bytes) 2007-01-05, 20:32:04 (118865)
在距离很近的时候 - 揍汉奸 (112 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:03:02 (118809)
- 计算超前量是很考技术的, - blessuuu (255 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:25:24 (118836)
  - 不矛盾啊！您好好读一下原文？ - 揍汉奸 (215 bytes) 2007-01-05, 20:07:14 (118855)
    - 看你自己的原文: - blessuuu (95 bytes) 2007-01-05, 20:21:48 (118861)
      - 您是否认为原文的描述是合理的呢？ (无内容) - 揍汉奸 (0 bytes) 2007-01-05, 20:31:07 (118864)
      - 说明 - 揍汉奸 (140 bytes) 2007-01-05, 20:29:19 (118863)
        
        你说的话,我没谈什么原来文章. - blessuuu (130 bytes) 2007-01-05, 20:55:52 (118872)
  - 在切半径的时候 - blessuuu (184 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:31:19 (118839)
- 今天晚上十点H channel - blessuuu (33 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:09:41 (118812)
  - that's my son's favor show, and he had never missed a single episode. (无内容) - steven (0 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:14:47 (118814)
    - 我倒 - blessuuu (11 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:53:08 (118849)
- Obviously you don't know dogfight. And "Yes," if both side - steven (123 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:06:28 (118810)
  - 呵呵，您老就不用冒充军事专家了 - 揍汉奸 (757 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:13:24 (118813)
    - close range, 2 feet? Is that what you mean? (无内容) - steven (0 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:15:42 (118815)
      - 您就不用抵赖了 - 揍汉奸 (65 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:17:23 (118816)
        
        yes, but not as what it is described in that article. (无内容) - steven (0 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:21:29 (118818)
        
        文章里面哪里有错？ - 揍汉奸 (455 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:59:09 (118824)
        
        改口改得很快嘛 - 揍汉奸 (235 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:25:59 (118820)
        
        请回答我的问题 - 揍汉奸 (139 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:21:13 (118834)
        
        你究竟想说什么？ - 揍汉奸 (84 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:14:23 (118830)
        
        who tells you dog fight means to aircrafts playing merry-go-round? - steven (169 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:02:30 (118826)
see it yourself - steven (558 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:03:00 (118808)
- 那又是谁告诉你在切半径时无法击落敌机 - 揍汉奸 (261 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:08:48 (118811)
  - 你对切半径战术理解有问题 - blessuuu (35 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:44:35 (118845)
    - 嗯，是有点搞混淆了 - 揍汉奸 (28 bytes) 2007-01-05, 20:34:29 (118866)
  - a shorter turn makes your enemy on your tail to overshoot. - steven (183 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:20:38 (118817)
    - 请勿顾左右而言它 - 揍汉奸 (126 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:24:04 (118819)
      - don't put your words into my mouth. I've never said that. (无内容) - steven (0 bytes) 2007-01-05, 18:56:03 (118823)
        
        贵人多忘事？ - 揍汉奸 (166 bytes) 2007-01-05, 19:02:42 (118827)

加跟贴