送交者: Latino2 于 2005-11-10, 12:31:55:

回答: 这说明肖没有被科学院院士们认可，并不能推论他说的都是牛皮 由 conner 于 2005-11-10, 12:24:21:

肖的文章太少。

Four papers in 20 years is too weak in publication records.

• He has tried. - coubert (0 bytes) 2005-11-10, 12:32:43
  • 谁有肖的“反射弧”在美国手术成功的具体数据？ - Latino2 (94 bytes) 2005-11-10, 13:15:43
    • If he always keep the weird reflection arc a secret and only he can - coubert (59 bytes) 2005-11-10, 15:43:38
      • oops. keeps - coubert (0 bytes) 2005-11-10, 15:44:05
    • 在美国的手术，公开报道两例 - Yush (380 bytes) 2005-11-10, 14:30:30
      • Now I see. Thanks. - Latino2 (43 bytes) 2005-11-10, 14:37:21
        • There is no science since there is no control - 大胖星 (754 bytes) 2005-11-10, 14:54:03
          • Shi-Min Chang's comment - Yush (590 bytes) 2005-11-10, 15:21:37
          • Where does the quote come from? Is it a reviewer's comment? - Latino2 (0 bytes) 2005-11-10, 15:12:06
            • http://print.nap.edu/pdf/0309095859/pdf_image/162.pdf - wasguru (0 bytes) 2005-11-10, 15:23:34
              • Ok, I found it form 立此存照.肖传国事件. Sorry for my ignorance. - Latino2 (0 bytes) 2005-11-10, 15:41:04
              • Thanks. - Latino2 (0 bytes) 2005-11-10, 15:33:48
        • this data alone doesn't show the whole picture - 匆匆过客 (225 bytes) 2005-11-10, 14:51:37
          • The question then is: Is it too early to know the real effect? - Latino2 (73 bytes) 2005-11-10, 15:11:06
            • I guess it depends on where you ask this question - 匆匆过客 (583 bytes) 2005-11-10, 15:27:04
              • Agree. But right now, it will very difficult to convince people - Latino2 (118 bytes) 2005-11-10, 15:44:00
                • 偶觉得逻辑上是这样：你只要说错一件事，你就是诬蔑 - xj (163 bytes) 2005-11-10, 16:38:21
                  • 这个官司即使输了也会“赢” - Yush (211 bytes) 2005-11-10, 17:07:04
    • agree. - 匆匆过客 (246 bytes) 2005-11-10, 13:47:34

加跟贴