送交者: 乱劈材 于 2005-3-31, 12:44:02:

比如说，一个学生被怀疑偷东西，同宿舍的人去翻查嫌疑人的私人物件，结果发现证据。从叙述来看，至少马PP偷更多人OFFER的新证据是被非警察人员自作主张翻出来的。

马能不能据此争辩这种私人侦探行为得到的证据不是证据？

• 如电话恐吓骚扰，可否合法录音，交给警察。 - meteor (0 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:57:30
  • Absolutely. (You wanna try it? what's your number? :) - Enlighten (0 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:59:17
• 这太容易被发现了 - Jingzhang2 (121 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:38:06
• 私人侦探偷拍的照片/录像能做证据吗。好像保险公司长干这事 - meteor (0 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:27:58
  • The court will weigh the interest of privacy vs. the interest of finding facts - Enlighten (401 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:40:28
    • 如果当事人自己拍录可以做为证据吗？ - meteor (4 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:46:17
      • 可以的，去年高院的司法解释 - haole (38 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:48:08
        • 你永远是是造谣后，狡辩。 - 百家姓 (62 bytes) 2005-3-31, 15:12:19
        • Fox New's anchor O'Reily was threatened lawsuit by his former - Enlighten (377 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:53:06
          • such recording is always legal. The only problem may have - steven (48 bytes) 2005-3-31, 15:10:03
        • 经对方同意而录音录像者还犯州法吧。 - meteor (0 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:51:09
          • 改正：不经对方同意而录音录像者还犯州法吧。 - meteor (0 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:51:48
            • 偶是说中土 - haole (0 bytes) 2005-3-31, 15:00:50
  • In US, court hold 私人侦探 to a higher standard - HunHunSheng (85 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:36:28
    • 中土私人侦探属于灰色地带，其取得证据的合法性有争议 - haole (78 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:41:46
• even in the USA, the 4th amendment onply aaplies to illegal search by government - HunHunSheng (719 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:29:44
  • 地主当然可以进入赁户家里，但是在这里可比性不对 - 乱劈材 (303 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:42:23
    • She can argue that but the evidence can be entered - HunHunSheng (276 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:58:30
  • without a search warrant from a judge? - meteor (101 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:41:24
    • Certain exigency can warantee police search without search warrant - HunHunSheng (801 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:47:58
      • what if the policy is not sure whether another person is in the apt? - Enlighten (104 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:57:51
        • Then he must have the good faith - HunHunSheng (762 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:03:31
      • In my first scenario, the police can enter apartment without warrant - HunHunSheng (321 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:51:28
        • Speaking of sighting, it reminds me of a case in which a lady - Enlighten (190 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:06:02
      • In my first scenario, the police can enter apartment without warrant - HunHunSheng (321 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:51:21
  • so the intention is more toward preventing government's abuse - Enlighten (40 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:32:39
    • Right. In my case, the landlord may be prosecuted too by trespassing - HunHunSheng (526 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:39:04
      • Assuminhg Person A is not giovernment law enforment personel - HunHunSheng (64 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:40:24
• 马是犯罪，和南大朱涵事件毫无共同之处，扯在一起莫名其妙 - haole (186 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:11:46
  • 因为是犯罪，就和非犯罪"毫无共同之处"? 小伪军haole逻辑混乱 - Jingzhang2 (50 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:34:30
  • 你就会变着法儿地诬蔑中国，在中国就可以违法？你也配谈法律？ - 百家姓 (16 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:28:13
    • 白痴不是你本人的错，可又何必光天化日来现眼？ - haole (406 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:12:44
      • 你丫的欠抽，你这个白痴，被版主抽了多少次， - 百家姓 (58 bytes) 2005-3-31, 14:58:55
• See! it's funny - 5672JTJ (55 bytes) 2005-3-31, 12:57:18
  • "Living learn and living use; Erect the pole and see the shadow". - Latino2 (0 bytes) 2005-3-31, 13:07:49

加跟贴