送交者: Enlighten 于 2005-1-30, 18:10:06:

回答: This is 文科。Scientific reasoning does not apply 由 skipper3 于 2005-1-30, 16:43:22:

If scientific reasoning does not apply to 文科, then what type of reasoning do you use? Without scientific methods, how do you prove what you propose? Will your proposal ever become more than just a "speculation"?
Are you saying there's some type of reasoning in 文科 that is unique and is superior to scientific reasoning? I'd really like to know about it.

• resoning alone means nothing to me. Whther it is - skipper3 (1049 bytes) 2005-1-30, 18:27:26
  • Different things - Enlighten (782 bytes) 2005-1-30, 18:58:57
    • Social science is not science. - skipper3 (350 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:11:17
      • Scientists don't always agree with one another and they aren't alway right - Enlighten (62 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:15:38
        • then everyone is using scientific methodology. - skipper3 (193 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:24:05
          • It is probably because "it's not scientific at all" - Enlighten (226 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:45:40
            • too many examples. give you one. - skipper3 (278 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:55:12
              • first one is not enough, second I'm not sure it applies - Enlighten (396 bytes) 2005-1-30, 20:03:38
                • what's point? - skipper3 (377 bytes) 2005-1-30, 20:21:18
                  • I agree it's BS. But the BS started when you said this - Enlighten (201 bytes) 2005-1-30, 20:31:54
  • for individual making a decision, you do the SuanZhang, - skipper3 (597 bytes) 2005-1-30, 18:45:15
    • Your assertion cannot be farther from the truth - Enlighten (524 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:08:34
      • whatever you call statistics. The fact is people - skipper3 (184 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:20:19
        • Science has reached there long ago - Enlighten (362 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:29:08
          • Pleeeeez! You are frustrating me. - skipper3 (320 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:34:56
            • You are changing the topic - Enlighten (450 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:52:47
              • don't jump the gun. - skipper3 (567 bytes) 2005-1-30, 20:07:08
                • Well, you oversimplified 理科 and attacked 理科人士 unfairly - Enlighten (651 bytes) 2005-1-30, 20:27:43

加跟贴