送交者: skipper3 于 2005-1-30, 12:25:12:

回答: NYTIMES reviews "Guns, Germs, and Steel" & "Collapse" 由 JZ 于 2005-1-30, 11:50:38:

• He gave his explaination, certainly not a perfect one. - Latino2 (101 bytes) 2005-1-30, 16:26:48
  • This is 文科。Scientific reasoning does not apply - skipper3 (443 bytes) 2005-1-30, 16:43:22
    • Question for skipper3 : 文科 vs. 理科 - Enlighten (367 bytes) 2005-1-30, 18:10:06
      • resoning alone means nothing to me. Whther it is - skipper3 (1049 bytes) 2005-1-30, 18:27:26
        • Different things - Enlighten (782 bytes) 2005-1-30, 18:58:57
          • Social science is not science. - skipper3 (350 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:11:17
            • Scientists don't always agree with one another and they aren't alway right - Enlighten (62 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:15:38
              • then everyone is using scientific methodology. - skipper3 (193 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:24:05
                • It is probably because "it's not scientific at all" - Enlighten (226 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:45:40
                  • too many examples. give you one. - skipper3 (278 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:55:12
                    • first one is not enough, second I'm not sure it applies - Enlighten (396 bytes) 2005-1-30, 20:03:38
                      • what's point? - skipper3 (377 bytes) 2005-1-30, 20:21:18
                        • I agree it's BS. But the BS started when you said this - Enlighten (201 bytes) 2005-1-30, 20:31:54
        • for individual making a decision, you do the SuanZhang, - skipper3 (597 bytes) 2005-1-30, 18:45:15
          • Your assertion cannot be farther from the truth - Enlighten (524 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:08:34
            • whatever you call statistics. The fact is people - skipper3 (184 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:20:19
              • Science has reached there long ago - Enlighten (362 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:29:08
                • Pleeeeez! You are frustrating me. - skipper3 (320 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:34:56
                  • You are changing the topic - Enlighten (450 bytes) 2005-1-30, 19:52:47
                    • don't jump the gun. - skipper3 (567 bytes) 2005-1-30, 20:07:08
                      • Well, you oversimplified 理科 and attacked 理科人士 unfairly - Enlighten (651 bytes) 2005-1-30, 20:27:43
    • What you said was along the same line. - Latino2 (266 bytes) 2005-1-30, 17:02:42
      • Diamond 的解释的要害是事后解释，偶可从中国和欧洲的历史来反驳 - xj (327 bytes) 2005-1-30, 17:43:49
        • 环境是个制约因素，人和社会本身才是社会发展的主要动力 - xj (842 bytes) 2005-1-30, 23:32:38
          • 全是瞎说. - fagus (378 bytes) 2005-1-31, 03:31:03
            • 小法你再这样眼光狭隘不讲道理，偶要学HUNHUN抵制你了 - xj (227 bytes) 2005-1-31, 13:15:34

加跟贴